Blog Archive
About Me
Monday, October 27, 2014
The Awakening Criticism
Patricia S. Yaeger voices her opinion on the main character Edna in ‘The Awakening.’ Yeager starts with describing Edna’s process of exploring her limitations of a woman, but using the word ‘attempt.’ Yaeger views Edna as a great start to making changes in women’s rights. She starts off wanting great change, leaving Leonce, distancing herself from her children, having multiple lovers, but ends up only hurting herself. Yaeger focuses greatly on the language, or lack there of, of Edna. She references times in the book that Edna was at a loss for words, mostly having to do with expressing any type of emotion. She states, ‘Edna’s silence offers a new dialogic ground from which we can measure the systematic distortions of her old ground of being and begin to construct a new, utopian image of women’s antithetical desire.’ Edna’s words failed her at times when her drastic actions got the point she so desperately need to get across. She sold her house without telling her husband, had relations with Alcee that were purely psychical, and did whatever she pleased without having to answer to anyone. Yaeger believes that Edna is strong for leaving what made her unhappy; her husband, children, motherhood, but was not strong enough to deal with the consequences of being liberated. Edna’s actions were a good start to help women gain freedom in a time of oppression, but her suicide at the end highlights the long road that is still ahead.
The Awakening Chapter 31-39
“His hand had strayed to her beautiful shoulders, and he could feel the response of her flesh to his touch” (125).
|
Arobin had stayed with Edna long after all the guests had left from her dinner party. She had been greatly affected by Victor’s impromptu performance of a song Robert once sung to her. Seeing that Edna was vulnerable, Arobin took advantage of her and acted as a form of emotional support. The way Chopin described their interaction makes the reader believe that Edna and Arobin had taken their relationship to the next level. Arobin believes that Edna is ‘responding to his touch,’ but it is more likely that Edna would have acted that way with any man that gave her attention.
|
“‘After a while,’ he (Robert) said, laying a cigar on the table” (144).
|
From the beginning chapters Robert is always smoking a cigarette, a poor mans smoke. A cigarette symbolizes an undeveloped man, while a cigar, which Leonce smokes, is elegant and manly. Robert returns to New Orleans and runs into Edna at a coffee shop. While having something to eat, Robert brings out a cigar which shocks Edna. The transition from cigarette to cigar is Robert’s transformation from a young, thoughtless man to a powerful and respectable man.
|
“”it was too late; the shore was far behind her, and her strength was gone” (157).
|
Edna discovers Roberts second sudden flee and goes into a deep depression. She does not care about Leonce, or Arobin, and only slightly about her two children. The night her and Robert spent together gave her false hope for the future, causing his withdrawal to have a crushing effect on her. After her visit with Victor, Edna’s depression deepens and she makes her way to the beach. Combined with her desperation and lack of ability to swim, Edna chooses to rid herself of all her troubles by drowning herself in the ocean that once meant freedom to her.
|
Wednesday, October 22, 2014
The Awakening: Chap 21-30
“‘nothing hereditary?’ he asked, seriously” (Chopin 89).
|
Leonce took his concerns regarding Edna to the family physician. He claims that Edna is not acting like herself, making him want to react violently. As soon as Edna begins to break out of the strict requirements Leonce has for her he makes ridiculous accusations that there must be something wrong with. That there is no logical answer for a woman to want more in life than to act as a slave for her husband and children. After his long rant on his wife’s recent actions the doctor asks if this condition, wanting to be treated with the slightest bit of respect, is hereditary. The fact that two men even entertain the fact that Edna not obeying her husband could be ‘hereditary’ accentuates the absurdity of men in the 1800s.
|
“She rummaged in the larder and brought forth a slice of Gruyere and some crackers. She opened a bottle of beer which she found in an icebox” (Chopin 101).
|
When her husband and children leave town, Edna is able to fully embrace the lifestyle she desperately longs to have. She meets a new man named Alcee who, much like Robert, is an intimate friend that tempts her to stray from her marriage. She is breaking out of all of her expected roles as a woman and a wife. She drinks beer, a drink associated with men, and at the beginning of the book she drank wine. Her switch of drink is highlighting her change in perspective. She was a sheltered women unhappy with her marriage and giving into the usual women behavior, drinking wine, obeying husband, and caring for her children. Now she is drinking beer, kissing men that are not her husband, and making decisions for her family without Leonce’s approval.
|
“But among the conflicting sensations that assailed her, there was neither shame nor regret” (Chopin 113).
|
After a kiss that was described as ‘a flaming torch of desire,’ Alcee left Edna to be alone with her thoughts. She went through multiple stages of emotions like shock and irresponsibility. It seemed to be expected that Edna would feel even the slightest bit of guilt after breaking her oath of marriage, but there was none. She did not see her kissing as disrespectful to Leonce, but to Robert. It would be more empowering for Edna to leave her unsatisfying marriage and pursue a relationship with Robert or Alcee or any other man, but she is still with
Leonce. Edna has made it clear that she values her own happiness and life over her children’s, so staying in the marriage is not for their benefit. She should leave Leonce and continue on her streak of empowerment.
|
The Awakening: Chapters 11-20
“the lovers, shoulders to shoulder, creeping; the lady in black, gaining steadily upon them” (44).
|
Edna and Leonce are on their way with most of town to attend a church service. As they are walking to the boat, Chopin specifically mentions the lovers and the lady in black accompanying them. The lovers are a symbol of the relationship that Edna and Leonce once had. The lovers are described as deeply as blissfully happy and walking ahead of The Pontellier’s, making the reader infer that their love is no longer present. The lady in black is most likely a widow, which could foreshadow Edna’s future. The lady is ‘gaining steadily upon them,’ symbolizing that the death of her marriage will be happening soon.
|
“her whole existence was dulled, faded garment which seems to be no longer worth wearing” (62).
|
Edna is beginning to realize how much Robert has affected her life. With hr loveless and empty marriage, Edna looked to Robert for the support and happiness a husband provides. Robert provided the emotional aspect of the marriage, while Leonce was more of a body and a person to give financial support. Edna realized the drastic difference in treatment between the two men. She was able to cope with the disappointment of her marriage by escaping, emotional and perhaps physically, with Robert. To her, a life without Robert was not worth living.
|
“But that evening, Edna finished her dinner alone, with forced deliberation. Her face flushed and her eyes flamed with inward fire” (70).
|
Leonce had been out all day doing whatever he pleased, whenever he pleased. He was not asked question when he came home from Edna, who herself was accused of being a bad mother for leaving the house with no excuse. She had prepared a meal for her husband only to have him criticize every aspect of it, saying it was too burnt to eat. Although small, this comment had pushed Enda over the edge. Years of these types of comments had made her sick of the treatment. Leonce ended up leaving the table to have dinner at the club, completely wasting her hard work. Edna’s determination to finished the burnt meal is her way of going against her husband. The action may have had little effect, but the fact that she made an effort is hinting at more extreme actions.
|
Tuesday, October 21, 2014
The Awakening: Chap 1-10
“Looking at his wife as one looks at a valuable piece of personal property which had suffered some damage” (Chopin 3).
|
This quotes stresses the type of relationship between a man and woman in the 1800s. It is said by Mr. Pontellier when describing his wife after a long day at the beach. His flippant and dismissive tone reveals his disappointment in the woman he married. He does not see her as a partner in life that is meant to be cherished and treated as an equal, he sees her as another thing he needs to keep control of. Mrs. Pontellier is worse than a piece of property to him, he sees her as damaged and worthless, which is clearer to see in their empty relationship as the book continues.
|
“In short, Mrs. Pontellier was not a mother-woman” (Chopin 10).
|
Mrs Pontellier’s parenting is now brought into questioning. By comparing her to other women on the island Chopin is furthering her point of the absurdity that women are targeted for doing the same thing men do. Because she does not give her full attention to her children at all times of the day, she is perceived as a bad mother. Because she likes when her children are gone to have some time to be alone with her thoughts, she could not possibly love her children. Mr. Pontellier left his wife and children for a whole day to gamble and drink with his friends but his absence is somehow acceptable because he is the man of the family. Wanting things as simple as time for yourself is something that is valued in today's society, but in the 1800s if a mother did these things that would be named unfit and uncaring.
|
“I wonder if I shall ever be stirred again as Mademoiselle Reisz’s playing moved me tonight” (Chopin 39).
|
Before the piano playing by Mademoiselle Reisz, Edna had simply been going through the motions of her life. She revealed that her marriage to Mr. Pontellier was an accident, a marriage out of spite to her father. Their marriage was empty of love, but full of unhappiness and silent wishing of freedom. The night she heard Mademoiselle play was the first time in many years she had felt a strong flooding of emotions that made her feel something more than andonheia she felt with her husband.
|
Friday, October 3, 2014
Happy Endings
'They buy a charming house' --> Factual Sentence
'John and Mary Die (X3)' --> Repition
'Eventually they all die' --> Simple Structure
'This other John will emerge like a butterfly from a cocoon' --> Simile
'Inside John, she thinks, is another John' --> Split Sentence
'If you like, it can be 'Madge' 'cancer' 'guilty and confused' and 'bird watching' --> Parallel Structure
'Now try How and Why' --> Imperatice Sentence
'Remember this is Canada' --> Telegraphic Sentence
'They both have hobbies which they find enjoyable while simultaneously challenging' --> Subjective
'He doesn't take off Mary's clothes, she takes the off herself, she acts like she's dying for it' --> Apostrophe Sentence
'John and Mary Die (X3)' --> Repition
'Eventually they all die' --> Simple Structure
'This other John will emerge like a butterfly from a cocoon' --> Simile
'Inside John, she thinks, is another John' --> Split Sentence
'If you like, it can be 'Madge' 'cancer' 'guilty and confused' and 'bird watching' --> Parallel Structure
'Now try How and Why' --> Imperatice Sentence
'Remember this is Canada' --> Telegraphic Sentence
'They both have hobbies which they find enjoyable while simultaneously challenging' --> Subjective
'He doesn't take off Mary's clothes, she takes the off herself, she acts like she's dying for it' --> Apostrophe Sentence
Wednesday, October 1, 2014
The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas
In 'The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas,' LeGuin illustrates the perfect society, with no conflicts or violence. The citizens are blissfully happy, ignoring the fact that a child must be kept in a basement completely shutout from society, basically fueling the joy of Omelas. Through situational irony, dark descriptive setting and symbolism, LeGuin exploits the shallow views that it is acceptable to benefit off of someone else's misfortune.
Omelas appears to be the perfect place to live, being described as a joyous environment filled with hardworking men and women. LeGuin goes into such specific detail on the town that it can only be interpreted as the ideal place to reside. With 'broad green meadows,' and 'miles of sunlit air,' it is hard to imagine anyone wanting to walk away from this place.
As the story continues, LeGuin reveals that there is a secret that has been swept under the rug. In order to keep this society running, one child of either gender must be sacrificed, put into a dark basement with no interactions or sunlight. The beautiful placed described in previous paragraph all depends on one child who is stripped from the right to experience that. This secret is ironic because the perfect place to live, work and raise a family is dependent on the hardship of a little child. As one boy plays outside on a never ending field with the sun shining, another is forced to sit in a dark dirty room wondering why he was chosen for this torture. LeGuin writes about this twisted society to force people to take a second glance at their own lives and see if they are ignoring someone else's struggles just because it furthers their own success. Some choose to leave Omelas, sick at the fact that one person has to be hurt in order for their happiness, a choice that seems to be obvious. Others continue living blind to the little secret, which is something that most people would choose.
Omelas appears to be the perfect place to live, being described as a joyous environment filled with hardworking men and women. LeGuin goes into such specific detail on the town that it can only be interpreted as the ideal place to reside. With 'broad green meadows,' and 'miles of sunlit air,' it is hard to imagine anyone wanting to walk away from this place.
As the story continues, LeGuin reveals that there is a secret that has been swept under the rug. In order to keep this society running, one child of either gender must be sacrificed, put into a dark basement with no interactions or sunlight. The beautiful placed described in previous paragraph all depends on one child who is stripped from the right to experience that. This secret is ironic because the perfect place to live, work and raise a family is dependent on the hardship of a little child. As one boy plays outside on a never ending field with the sun shining, another is forced to sit in a dark dirty room wondering why he was chosen for this torture. LeGuin writes about this twisted society to force people to take a second glance at their own lives and see if they are ignoring someone else's struggles just because it furthers their own success. Some choose to leave Omelas, sick at the fact that one person has to be hurt in order for their happiness, a choice that seems to be obvious. Others continue living blind to the little secret, which is something that most people would choose.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)