Ernest Hemingway describes the struggle between a man and a girl as they attempt to come to a resolution in regards to a heavy topic. Hemingway skillfully uses third person narrative, limited dialogue and symbolism to unravel the complicated relationship and affirm that communication is vital in order to make sure each person is content in the relationship.
The narrator simply gives the reader the basic details of the man and the girl. There is no insight into their deepest thoughts, which makes deciphering the message more difficult. It allows Hemingway to illustrate the wall between the two characters, indirectly showing that there is an obvious problem between the two. By limiting the narrator's knowledge of the characters, Hemingway magnifies the character's own difficulty to understand one another's thoughts.
The only topic the man and the girl seem to talk about openly is the alcohol they are drinking. They are at a train station in Spain, waiting for the next outgoing ride. It seemed that Hemingway picked this specific location to symbolize the urgency of the choice they had to make, that there was a time limit that was approaching quickly. The choice they needed to make was unclear at first because of they way they danced around the topic, talking code, because when they said they actual word their situation would become a reality. The girl seemed unsure of what choice she wanted to make. It did not help that the man was playing off the operation as if it were no big deal, stating, 'I wouldn't have you do it if you don't want to. But i know it is perfectly simple'. This seems to be enough to convince the girl to go through with the operation, which now is suggested that it is an abortion. At the end of the story, the man leaves the girl alone at such a vulnerable time, furthering the distance that was already between them. He picks up their bags and brings the closer to the tracks. Physically carrying his own, and now they woman's emotional baggage that comes with the operation. The man and the girl never openly agreed on what was to be done, but when he returns back to the bar, he asks the girl is she is alright and she responds saying 'I'm fine'. The story ends with no finality for not only the reader but for the man and the girl.
Tuesday, September 30, 2014
Wednesday, September 24, 2014
I Stand Here Ironing: Tillie Olsen
In the short piece 'I Stand Here Ironing,' Olsen puts the effects of single parenting under magnification with the use of a desperate tone, reflective first person point of view, and deceptively simple syntax to characterize the mother.
The story is told from the point of view of the mother, revealing her inner most thoughts throughout her parenting with her first child Emily. The mother is not given a name, further emphasizing the fact that the main focus should be on Emily and the other four children. Her desperate and helpless tone urges the reader to step into her shoes and see what the reality of raising children on her own is like.
She tried her hardest to bring Emily up in a loving home, but as more children were born Emily was put on the back burner. The mother admits that Emily has to act as 'mother, and a housekeeper, and a shopper' (pg 296). Olsen keeps her sentences short and to the point coming off as simple but in in reality accentuates the feeling of desperation and close to giving up. Despite the mother feeling like she had failed Emily, she thrives on her own and turns to preforming as a release for her home life. The mother looks back at her parenting and sees that despite her lack of presence Emily is able to flourish. Emily's accomplishment proves that even if there is no parental figure involved in a child's life, it is possible for them to succeed in life.
Tuesday, September 23, 2014
Monday, September 22, 2014
Cathedral: Raymond Carver
- The author never introduces himself to the reader. He starts off with saying how his wife’s, no name given, blind friend is coming to stay with them in order to avoid the loneliness of his own wife’s death. The blind man, Robert, is a large part of the narrator’s wife’s past. She was his aid during a summer in seattle and kept in touch with him throughout the period of dating. The narrator is very territorial of his home and wife, and makes all sorts of jokes before Robert’s arrival to ease his wandering thoughts. Despite his judgemental actions, the narrator gives Roberts a chance and found that he disapproved all stereotypes of blind people.
- The narrator’s own judgements carry over to the readers, making the audience feel anxious and even protective of their home. The feels like he needs to prove himself to Robert because of his extensive history with his wife. It seemed like the wife would share everything with Robert, and that the narrator was like the third friend that is always kept in the dark. The beginning paragraphs of the story the narrator makes snide comments to Robert, mocking his disability and is disrespected when Robert calls him ‘Bub’ (5).
- Blindness is the main focus point in the short story Cathedral. The wife and the narrator have complete opposite views on blindness.The wife is understanding and empathetic, while the narrator is skeptical of the strange man coming into his house, and allows his ignorance and preconceived stereotype to skew his view of Robert. The wife tries to make the narrator understand Robert, telling him about the death of his wife Beluah. Beluah dies of cancer, never once seen through the eyes of her lover. The narrator gets new perspective on Robert's impairment, and how it affects others as well as himself. The narrator lets go of his stereotypical judgement of blind men that he obtained through movies, which aids the change of opinions.
- When attempting to illustrate a cathedral to Robert, the narrator finds sudden peace and clarity. He closes his eyes and lets his hand guide his thoughts. This epiphany is the narrator finally experiencing what it is like to be in Robert's shoes. He keeps his eyes closed longer than needed and states, 'I was in my house. I knew that. But I didn't feel like i was inside anything'. The story ends suddenly, with the narrator still in an out of body experience. The author chooses not to include what exactly happened to the narrator to explore the feeling of blindness. The audience cannot see what the narrator is going through because they are only reading it, not experiencing the feeling.
- To the reader, it seems as though the narrator and wife are two stranger living under the same roof. The wife seems full of opinions and love. The narrator does love the wife, as we can see from his inner thoughts, but struggles to voice them. Carver does a excellent job of simply explaining their situation the best he can to the reader. It may seem strange to an outsider, but the way they function works for them. They stay together and are content with their lives. It is not our place to judge how a relationship works. It does seem strange that the only excitement they have in their life is because of a distant blind friend.
Friday, September 19, 2014
Character Development
Joyce Carol Oates introduced naive fifteen year old Connie who attempts to find a source of happiness in the short story, Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been? Through heightened emotions and deep thoughts Gilman magnifies the the importance of having stable and supportive people to fall back on. Being unusually pretty, Connie's mother targets her unique features and makes sure Connie feels ashamed of her looks. Her father barely acknowledges anyone’s existence, focusing on work and his own needs. In order to escape her home life, Connie takes to daydreaming and chasing boys with friends. She desperately tried to escape her life, 'dreaming and dazed with the warmth about her as if this were a kind of love, the caresses of love, and her mind slipped into thoughts of the boy' (pg2). Connie's childish thoughts and illusions are quickly diminished when she she comes into contact with Arnold.
At first intrigued, Connie learns that the Arnold is not at all what he claims to be. He is not close to Connie’s age, but rather a middle aged man. Oates uses intense imagery to launch the perception that Arnold is not trustworthy and opposes some sort of a threat to Connie’s innocence. She ends up going with Arnold, the obvious wrong choice to the reader. Connie's family didn't want anything to do with her, and therefore she had to way to know what was morally right and what was morally wrong.
At first intrigued, Connie learns that the Arnold is not at all what he claims to be. He is not close to Connie’s age, but rather a middle aged man. Oates uses intense imagery to launch the perception that Arnold is not trustworthy and opposes some sort of a threat to Connie’s innocence. She ends up going with Arnold, the obvious wrong choice to the reader. Connie's family didn't want anything to do with her, and therefore she had to way to know what was morally right and what was morally wrong.
Thursday, September 18, 2014
Setting Analysis: The Yellow Wallpaper
Gilman successfully establishes the eery atmosphere in The Yellow Wallpaper, as the main character struggles to overcome the demons inside of her. The short story was written during the late-1800s, a time where women had little rights. The majority of the story takes place in the attic of the house. To the main character the attic was once used as a nursery, but to the reader it is easy to see that the barred windows and nailed down bed were not for the children’s safety, but her own. The woman is battling mental illness alone because her husband and any other doctors she sees is convinced that nothing is wrong, and is sentenced to a three month stay in the attic. The beginning of the story the woman is feeling lost and depressed. No one believes anything is wrong with her, which makes her even more paranoid and crazy.
Her husband, John, comes off as more of a father figure to the woman than a partner who should be helping her through this dark time. His adamant comments about the attic being the best thing for her makes him seem deceitful and give the story a haunting vibe. While she is in the attic, the wallpaper seems to be speaking to her. It may just be her illness, but the woman seems to think there is another woman trapped inside the wallpaper. The wallpaper used to be a symbol of her illness, but it is a symbol for her freedom. It is ironic that the object that turned the woman mad, is now the thing that has given her clarity. If the woman had not gone through the struggle and mental brutality, she would not have found the strength leave a bad situation for herself. She is first oppressed, by John, the wallpaper, Jane and even herself. The author shows how liberation is necessary to better oneself and the position they are in.
Her husband, John, comes off as more of a father figure to the woman than a partner who should be helping her through this dark time. His adamant comments about the attic being the best thing for her makes him seem deceitful and give the story a haunting vibe. While she is in the attic, the wallpaper seems to be speaking to her. It may just be her illness, but the woman seems to think there is another woman trapped inside the wallpaper. The wallpaper used to be a symbol of her illness, but it is a symbol for her freedom. It is ironic that the object that turned the woman mad, is now the thing that has given her clarity. If the woman had not gone through the struggle and mental brutality, she would not have found the strength leave a bad situation for herself. She is first oppressed, by John, the wallpaper, Jane and even herself. The author shows how liberation is necessary to better oneself and the position they are in.
Tuesday, September 16, 2014
Yellow Wallpaper: Charlotte Perkins Gilman
Question 1:
The start of the story the narrator sees the wallpaper as an annoyance. It is bothersome, and prevents her from getting any sleep. The author reveals that she has some sort of condition, but her husband, a physician, does not believes that she is sick. Her husband locks her in a room which she believes to be a nursery, in hopes of curing the condition. To the narrator, the wallpaper appears to be dull, faded and depressing, much like her disease. She yearns to leave the room and live near the piazza, surrounded by roses and scenery. As the story continues on, the author becomes farther and farther disconnected to her life, slipping into a type of fantasy world that allows her imagination to run wild. The more time she spends in the room, the more she thinks about the wallpaper. She seems to think there is a woman trying to get out of the wallpaper, just like she is stuck in the attic. The wallpaper is no longer a symbol of irritation, but now of the freedom she wishes has. The woman trapped in the wallpaper is comparison to the roles of women in society during that time. Even though the narrator believed she was getting better, her actions and paranoia made me feel like she was becoming even more insane.
Question 2:
The narrator believes that her living space was a former nursery. John tells her that the nursery is the perfect spot because of the open. airy room. It is obvious her mind is not sharp because of the way she easily believes that the, ‘windows are barred for little children,’ when really they are barred in order to keep her from doing any sort of harm to herself (1067). the narrator spends so much time in her room that she finds similarities in herself and the wallpaper. Finally, she see that the wallpaper is keeping a woman inside, not allowing there to have any room to live. The narrator goes completely crazy, only to find sanity in the very place that is containing her from any contact.
Question 4:
Due to the narrator's condition, she is unable to keep her thoughts in check. The sentences and syntax are choppy and random thoughts trail into current ones, further emphasizing the reality of the disease. She says one thing, then completely contradicts herself in the next. She describes the wallpaper as, 'connecting diagonally, and then sprawling outlines run off in great slanting waves of optic horror" (1071). The wallpaper mirrors her thoughts and actions, showing the reader the severity of her mental state.
Monday, September 8, 2014
It's Never Just an Illness
Using the techniques obtained from How to Read Literature Like a Professor by Thomas Foster, I had found a deeper meaning to almost everything described in Zora Hurston's novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God. In chapter 26, Foster reveals to the reader that when a character is given an illness, it is never random. Every type of heart attack and cancer is carefully thought out by the author to symbolize something a character is going through. Foster stresses the fact that, "all diseases are not created equal", and that a reader must pay close attention to catch these hidden meanings (Foster, 222).
Finally, Tea Cake comes into the picture. Their love is crazy and full of passion.Janie worked willingly in the fields to be closer to him, wore expensive clothing and let her hair flow freely. All three are things she never could have done in her past relationships. Him being much younger than Janie, makes the relationship even more appealing to her. The two seem to be able to overcome all obstacles thrown their way, the age difference, speculations that Tea Cake is using Janie for her money, but still stay together. The thing that breaks them apart is the horrible mental illness Tea Cake acquires from a dog bite. Tea Cake saved Janie from a dog attack, sacrificing himself. His mind and body is then taken over by rabies. I did not understand why Hurston chose that specific disease, it could have been a cold or the flu. I now think that the rabies was a way to show the love between Janie and Tea Cake. It was a crazy, consuming type of love, just like how the rabies made Tea Cake spiral out of control almost killing Janie.
If I had read Hurston's book without reading How to Read Literature Like a Professor beforehand, I would have missed major signs that could have given me an insight into the authors's reasoning. The main character Janie, experiences an immense amount of loss from a young age. Her mother had left her when she was young, leaving Janie to be raised by her grandmother. Her grandmother dies of old age, which is just as boring and plain as her relationship with Janie. Next we get to know Logan, the man Janie's grandmother forced her to marry. Logan being a unloving and unappreciative husband, was left by Janie when a handsome suitor named Jodie swept her off her feet. Caught up in the excitement of running away, Janie and Jodie are blissfully happy in the honeymoon stage. Years into their marriage Janie has realized Jodie is constantly being belittling her, but again gets herself out of that relationship. Jodie dies from kidney failure, where he is described in great detail to be wasting away and his body 'like bags hanging form an iron board" (Hurston, 81). His disease is pretty common and Janie has no sympathy towards him, which can be interpreted as the loss of love and emotion between the two.
Finally, Tea Cake comes into the picture. Their love is crazy and full of passion.Janie worked willingly in the fields to be closer to him, wore expensive clothing and let her hair flow freely. All three are things she never could have done in her past relationships. Him being much younger than Janie, makes the relationship even more appealing to her. The two seem to be able to overcome all obstacles thrown their way, the age difference, speculations that Tea Cake is using Janie for her money, but still stay together. The thing that breaks them apart is the horrible mental illness Tea Cake acquires from a dog bite. Tea Cake saved Janie from a dog attack, sacrificing himself. His mind and body is then taken over by rabies. I did not understand why Hurston chose that specific disease, it could have been a cold or the flu. I now think that the rabies was a way to show the love between Janie and Tea Cake. It was a crazy, consuming type of love, just like how the rabies made Tea Cake spiral out of control almost killing Janie.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)